Gumroad vs Sellfy
Gumroad and Sellfy both help creators sell digital products, but they price it very differently: Gumroad takes a cut of each sale with no monthly cost, while Sellfy charges a monthly plan and doesn't take a transaction cut. Sellfy also adds print-on-demand merch, which Gumroad doesn't do. Your choice hinges on your sales volume and whether you want to sell physical merch too.
Quick answer
Choose Gumroad if you want zero monthly cost and the simplest way to start selling a digital product, and you're fine paying a percentage per sale; choose Sellfy if you sell enough that a flat monthly plan with no per-sale cut works out cheaper, or you want built-in print-on-demand merch. Compare their current pricing against your real volume before deciding. If you'd rather pay no platform cut at all, OneSol is a free all-in-one alternative that pays straight into your own Stripe.
Gumroad vs Sellfy at a glance
| Feature | Gumroad | Sellfy |
|---|---|---|
| Free to start | Yes (free) | Free trial |
| Pricing model | Per-sale fee | Monthly plan |
| Cut on sales | Per-sale % | 0% (pay monthly) |
| Print-on-demand merch | No | Yes |
| Digital products & subscriptions | Yes | Yes |
| Store customization | Limited | More |
| Email marketing | Built-in | Built-in |
| Ease of use | Very easy | Easy |
Competitor features and pricing can change — check their current plans before deciding.
Gumroad vs Sellfy: what each one actually costs
Sell a $29 product 25 times — $725 of sales in a month — and Sellfy leaves you $56 more than Gumroad. Both rates come from the platform’s own published pricing, on the dates below.
“For sales made on Gumroad's website, we charge a 10% + $0.50 fee + sales tax per transaction. This does not include: Credit card processing (2.9% + $0.30) / PayPal fees”Gumroad pricing — checked 2026-09-17
“No, Sellfy does not charge a transaction fee. When you choose a plan that works for you depending on your yearly transaction volume, no additional fees will be charged.”Sellfy pricing — checked 2026-09-17
For reference, OneSol takes no cut of sales at all — customers pay into your own Stripe or PayPal — and Pro is a flat $9 a month. Run your own numbers across 18 platforms.
1. Where Gumroad fits best
Gumroad is the natural pick when you're starting out or selling irregularly, because there's no monthly bill to justify. You only pay when you make a sale, which keeps the risk low, though that per-sale percentage becomes the expensive part once volume climbs.
2. Where Sellfy fits best
Sellfy rewards consistent sellers: you pay a fixed monthly fee and keep the full sale price, which flips the math in your favor at higher volumes. It also bundles print-on-demand merch and more storefront customization, making it a fit for creators who want products beyond digital files.
3. The cost that's easy to miss
The crossover point matters most. Gumroad's per-sale cut is invisible until you're selling a lot, and Sellfy's monthly fee is dead weight if you sell little. Estimate your monthly revenue and compare the two structures directly rather than assuming the cheaper headline is the cheaper platform.
The verdict
OneSol gives you one link to sell digital products, run forms, take bookings and capture emails — with payments landing directly in your own Stripe and no platform cut on top. Instead of choosing between Gumroad's per-sale percentage and Sellfy's monthly subscription, you keep 100% of each sale minus only Stripe's standard fee, and get more than a storefront in the bargain.
FAQ
Does Sellfy charge a transaction fee like Gumroad?
Sellfy's plans generally don't take a percentage of each sale — you pay a monthly fee instead. Gumroad takes a cut per sale with no monthly cost, so the better deal depends on how much you sell.
Can I sell physical merch on Gumroad?
Gumroad focuses on digital products and doesn't offer print-on-demand. Sellfy has built-in print-on-demand merch, so it's the stronger choice if you want to sell branded physical items.
Which is easier for a beginner?
Both are beginner-friendly. Gumroad is the fastest to start because there's no plan to choose, while Sellfy gives you more storefront control once you're set up.
Is there a way to sell without any platform cut or monthly fee?
Yes — OneSol is free, takes no cut of your sales, and pays directly into your own Stripe, so you keep 100% minus only Stripe's standard processing fee, with forms and bookings included.